HORSEHEADS FIRST UNITED METHODIST CHURCH. Annual Fall Rummage Sale. 1034 West Broad Street, Horseheads, NY. 14845. Starting Oct. 1, from 5 PM to 8 PM. Oct. 2, from 8 AM to 4 PM. and on Oct. 3, from 8 AM to Noon. Something for everyone. Jewelry, personal care items, linens, dishes, table top appliances, crafts, patterns, toys, cook books, books, men/women/children clothes in all sizes. Shoes, purses, luggage, crib, 1 child's bed, patio set, tools, baskets, collectibles, knick·knack, Christmas items, something for everyone.